Skip to content
Tankless Costs Guide

Electric vs Gas Tankless Water Heater: Costs and Features Compared (2026)

Updated November 2026

Short answer: electric tankless heaters cost less to buy and install, roughly $650 – $2,500, but cost more to run and deliver less hot water. Gas models cost roughly $1,650 – $3,500 installed, cost less to run and suit larger homes. Check what your home already has: a gas line and vent, or spare electrical capacity, often decides it.

ElectricNatural gas
Unit$500 – $1,500$750 – $2,000
Installation$150 – $1,000$900 – $1,500
Total installed$650 – $2,500$1,650 – $3,500
Main extrasNew circuit $200 – $600, panel upgrade $1,000 – $2,000Gas line $350 – $750, venting $400 – $800
Running cost per yearAbout $340 – $540About $190 – $265
Hot water outputLower; best for smaller homes and point of useHigher; suits whole-house use
Sources: This Old House, updated June 2026 (installed costs and extras; gas running cost); HomeGuide, 2026 (electric running cost). Running costs depend on your local energy prices.

When electric makes sense

Choose electric if you have no gas line, a smaller household, a warm climate or a point-of-use job such as a single bathroom. Electric needs no venting, which keeps installation cheap. The catch is power: a whole-house unit can need 120 to 160 amps of dedicated service and several 240-volt circuits, and many older homes need a panel upgrade.

When gas makes sense

Choose gas if you already have natural gas, a larger household or cold groundwater. Gas units heat more water per minute and cost less to run, but they need a sealed vent and often a larger gas line, which is why installation costs more. Propane works too, but costs more to run than natural gas.

Watch the flow rate: rated GPM assumes a small temperature rise. In a cold climate the flow you actually get can be about half the rating, which hurts electric units most. Check the manufacturer’s flow table for your groundwater temperature.

The federal tax credit for tankless heaters ended for equipment installed after December 31, 2025, so check your utility for rebates. For full breakdowns, see our gas tankless guide and electric tankless guide, or price your own job with our calculator.